A filmmaker touched off a debate in Pakistan revolving round one query – can a Facebook friend request ever be regarded as harassment?
It started with a discuss with to the health facility by way of the sister of Oscar-award successful Pakistani filmmaker Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy. After the remedy, the sister gained a friend request from her physician.
That brought on an indignant Twitter outburst by way of the filmmaker – and a social media hurricane in regards to the definition of harassment:
Obaid-Chinoy’s description of the Facebook request as “harassment” induced an indignant reaction from many Pakistanis claiming she had overreacted. Others supported her, claiming the regularly abusive response she gained printed the misogyny of her critics.
One of Obaid-Chinoy’s maximum vocal detractors was once journalist Ali Moeen Nawazish, who wrote on his personal Facebook web page that evaluating a social media request to harassment was once “ridiculous.” He added “Whats next, asking for a pen is harassment… Looking at someone for three seconds will be harassment???”
In his put up, he additionally stated that the declare “is actually taking away from real victims of harassment.”
You may also be occupied with:
The journalist concluded by way of criticising Obaid-Chinoy for “Pakistan shaming.”
Nawazish later claimed that the physician have been fired as a results of the tweets, then again reviews point out that he has been suspended from Aga Khan University Hospital in Karachi whilst an interior investigation takes position.
Obaid-Chinoy, who received approval for her documentaries on “honour killings” and acid assault sufferers, has confronted an identical accusations previously. She’s been accused of being a “traitor” to Pakistan in the case of her paintings which exposes violent and misogynistic cultural traditions prevalent in sure portions of Pakistani society. Her tweet hurricane renewed the ones criticisms and he or she was once time and again accused of getting harmed the rustic’s world symbol.
Some recommended she exemplified the word “wrong women in the wrong family” and referred to as her an elitist. She, then again, therefore clarified she was once regarding the truth that “women in my family are strong” and had no longer supposed to “suggest a sense of privilege or power.”
But that did not prevent many Pakistanis on Twitter from attacking the filmmaker. Some posted images of her with different males – it seems that suggesting those photographs made her a hypocrite for complaining about alleged harassment. Facebook pages have been created encouraging folks to ship Obaid-Chinoy friend requests.
Many others, together with each women and men, wondered whether or not a friend request amounted to harassment.
But Obaid-Chinoy did to find some give a boost to in newspaper columns and on social media. her defenders incorporated they incorporated Pakistani creator Bina Shah, who advised the BBC she wasn’t shocked by way of “the kind of abuse and vitriol” directed on the filmmaker.
“Any time you try to fight against (the patriarchy) you get an immediate backlash,” Shah stated.
In a next remark Obaid-Chinoy wrote that “The conversation has unfortunately steered far from the safety of women, unchecked unethical practises & harassment.”
She printed that the physician in query had performed a “very private examination” of her sister ahead of logging on and “leaving comments on photographs & trying to add her as a Facebook friend.”
She clarified she often receives “unsolicited friendship requests from strangers” however that she regarded as this episode a “serious breach of patient-doctor privilege.”
The Pakistan Medical and Dental Council referred the BBC to their moral tips, which do not particularly point out social media however do state that a “professional position must never be used to pursue a relationship of an emotional or sexual nature with a patient, the patient’s spouse, or a near relative of a patient.”
The physician on the centre of the debate has no longer been named publicly. He has, then again, reportedly gained a activity be offering from some other health facility in Karachi.
Blog by way of Secunder Kermani
More from Trending: ‘Lack of compromise’ introduced Civil War
President Trump’s leader of workforce, General John Kelly, claims an incapacity to compromise led to the American Civil War. The social media response got here fast…READ MORE
You can observe BBC Trending on Twitter @BBCtrending, and to find us on Facebook. All our tales are at bbc.com/trending.